If your credit has taken a hit, your car insurance bill may have taken one too. A new NerdWallet analysis, also reported by FOX21 News, found that drivers with poor credit have seen some of the steepest price increases of the last three years, even with a clean driving record. Here's what the numbers show, how Colorado law limits the way insurers use your credit, and what Colorado Springs drivers can do about it.
How much more drivers with poor credit pay
NerdWallet's 2026 rate analysis compared full-coverage prices for a 35-year-old driver from January 2023 to January 2026. According to NerdWallet:
Poor credit, clean record: the median yearly rate rose 37.7%, to $3,944.
Good credit, clean record: the median rate rose 32.3%, to $2,359. That's about $1,585 a year less than the same driver with poor credit.
Credit vs. a crash: a driver with poor credit and a clean record now pays more than a driver with good credit and an at-fault accident ($3,503).
Poor credit and a DUI: $7,013 a year, the biggest increase in the study at 40.4%.
These are estimates for one driver profile, so your price will depend on your car, your coverage and your history. Still, the pattern is clear: where it's allowed, credit can move your premium as much as your driving record does.
Can insurers use your credit in Colorado?
Yes. California, Hawaii and Massachusetts don't allow insurers to use credit to set auto rates, according to NerdWallet, but Colorado does. Insurers here can use a credit-based insurance score, built from parts of your credit report, along with your driving record, your vehicle and the coverage you choose. The same rules apply to homeowners insurance.
Colorado law (C.R.S. 10-4-116) limits how insurers use credit:
Credit can't be the only reason. An insurer can't deny, cancel or refuse to renew your policy because of credit without also considering a factor that has nothing to do with credit.
Some things can't count against you, including medical debts in collections, credit inquiries you didn't make, verified identity theft, and credit hurt by a divorce or a former spouse.
Thin credit isn't automatically bad. If there isn't enough credit history for a score, the insurer generally has to treat you as neutral or rate you without credit.
Some factors are off-limits. Insurance scores can't be based on income, gender, address, ZIP code, ethnic group, religion, marital status or nationality.
Your rights if credit raises your rate
Get the reasons. If credit leads to a higher rate, a denial or another adverse action, the insurer must tell you, describe up to four main reasons in plain language and name the credit bureau that supplied the report.
Check your report. You can get a free copy of that report within 60 days and dispute anything that's wrong. If a dispute corrects your report, the insurer must re-rate your policy within 30 days and refund any overcharge from up to the past 12 months.
Ask for a re-rate at renewal. If your credit has improved, you or your agent can ask the insurer to re-rate your policy with a current credit report at your annual renewal.
How to lower your car insurance with bad credit
Compare more than one company. Insurers weigh credit differently. A NerdWallet analysis of October 2026 rates found that in about half of ZIP codes in states that allow credit scoring, the cheapest company for a driver with poor credit wasn't the cheapest for a driver with good credit. As an independent agency in Colorado Springs, we compare several companies for you at once.
Raise your deductible, but only to an amount you could pay after a claim.
Set up automatic payments and don't miss one. Some insurers give a small discount for it.
Skip small claims you can afford to pay yourself, like a minor windshield crack.
Match coverage to your car. If you could replace an older car yourself, dropping collision and comprehensive can lower your premium. Keep in mind that comprehensive is what pays for hail damage, and Colorado still requires liability coverage of at least 25/50/15.
Bundle your policies. See bundling home and auto insurance in Colorado Springs.
Rebuild your credit over time, then ask for that re-rate at renewal.
Buying a different car? Get a quote before you sign. Our post on why replacing your car can raise your insurance shows what to check first. And if the state requires you to file proof of insurance, see SR-22 insurance in Colorado Springs.
Get a quote from a local agent
Not sure how much your credit is costing you? McCloskey Advisor Group is an independent insurance agency in Colorado Springs. We'll compare rates from multiple insurance companies and help you find coverage that fits your budget. Request a free auto insurance quote or call (719) 247-1554.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Sources: NerdWallet, "Car Insurance Soars for Drivers With Poor Credit; Here's What to Do" (Nov. 10, 2026), also reported by FOX21 News; C.R.S. 10-4-116; C.R.S. 10-4-616; Colorado Division of Insurance, Auto Insurance.